I'm 17, and pay $1400 a year for 1 vehicle with basic coverage. It does not even matter how old the vehicle is, my '73 VW camper --> $1400/year, '99 VW Jetta TDI --> $1400/year.
Ah, middle of nowhere, be glad you do live in the MIDDLE OF NOWHERE.
Come to the other great big cities of Canada where there is no socialist Gov't Insurance program , like Toronto, and you will
easily pay 6-7 times that amount.
If you are under your parents insurance, that is living in their domicile, then that is not a bad rate.
If your are living on your own then that is a truly a good bargoon.
In 1978 the best rate I got at your age was $ 350.00/year living on my own driving a crap box BMC Austin Mini, with only PL & PD,and comprehensive capped at $250,000.
Today it is still a crap box Geo Metro, with only PL & PD, no fire, no theft and no collision capped at $ 2 mil. and for that I get the previlege of paying capitalist rates of $ 1100/year in good ole T.O.
And that was the same for the 84 Benz or the 99 Geo.
I'm luckier with the Silver Plan for my "classic" Mgb and Tr8 far cheaper but mucho restrictions.
So count your blessings, there are worse places to be.
.