31
Everything else / Re: KISS vs COMPLEX, tell us what you are doing
« on: August 02, 2009, 10:35:13 PM »
Hi All
For anyone interested the Prestolite/Leece Neville 110-555JHO alternator can be viewed here:
http://www.prestolite.com/literature/alts/PP1131_110-555.pdf
Shows the J180 mounting specs. Has a nice Output/RPM performance graphed.
These are on eBay used and new all of the time.
MobileBob the performance curve shows the real story, eh? 160 amps at 4000RPM and it will do that all day without overheating. 20,000 hour rated bearings.
I too get asked and try to explain to people why this proven performance will always beat a small frame light weight unit that if you do manage to cram enough PM's in it (or jam enough field current into it like Lestec and Phoenix Gold did) and spin it fast enough to kick out this same wattage you WILL NOW HAVE TO spin it 14-16,000 RPM to suck enough air through it to keep it from melting down. Think of the Noise!
Bearings are only going to last ~ 500 hours! I know, I saw this as a Lestec/Phoenix Gold dealer in the 80's.
It is hard to convince people that nothing beats the hugh hunk of properly formed iron mass for magnetism and thermal heat sinking in a large framed unit. You know this and Doug knows this and a few others.
I think the fascination is with the new must be better. Sex sells. Sells a lot of bright, shiny new made in India 19", 20" and 21" wheels and tires onto PU's and SUV's that Will Not give you better milage, Will Not last as long, are hard to balance, Will cost More to service and replace. Other than pretty their only value is to successfully transfer money from your pocket into the hand of the sellers.
Same with these small framed automotive PM alternator conversions.
BTW I still owe you an old Electrodyne core for your help in the past.
Regards
SteveU.
For anyone interested the Prestolite/Leece Neville 110-555JHO alternator can be viewed here:
http://www.prestolite.com/literature/alts/PP1131_110-555.pdf
Shows the J180 mounting specs. Has a nice Output/RPM performance graphed.
These are on eBay used and new all of the time.
MobileBob the performance curve shows the real story, eh? 160 amps at 4000RPM and it will do that all day without overheating. 20,000 hour rated bearings.
I too get asked and try to explain to people why this proven performance will always beat a small frame light weight unit that if you do manage to cram enough PM's in it (or jam enough field current into it like Lestec and Phoenix Gold did) and spin it fast enough to kick out this same wattage you WILL NOW HAVE TO spin it 14-16,000 RPM to suck enough air through it to keep it from melting down. Think of the Noise!
Bearings are only going to last ~ 500 hours! I know, I saw this as a Lestec/Phoenix Gold dealer in the 80's.
It is hard to convince people that nothing beats the hugh hunk of properly formed iron mass for magnetism and thermal heat sinking in a large framed unit. You know this and Doug knows this and a few others.
I think the fascination is with the new must be better. Sex sells. Sells a lot of bright, shiny new made in India 19", 20" and 21" wheels and tires onto PU's and SUV's that Will Not give you better milage, Will Not last as long, are hard to balance, Will cost More to service and replace. Other than pretty their only value is to successfully transfer money from your pocket into the hand of the sellers.
Same with these small framed automotive PM alternator conversions.
BTW I still owe you an old Electrodyne core for your help in the past.
Regards
SteveU.