Puppeteer

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Timbo

Pages: [1]
1
I have a 6/1 driving a 5KW gen head and live in Falls Church, VA.  Any excuse to fire it up is appreciated!

email me and I'll be glad to have you over,

Timbo

2
Kinda hate to play devil's advocate, but does anyone truly know of anybody seriously injured by one of these things?

We live in a society that is becoming more and more risk averse - why are we fanning the risk flame by insinuating that these things are more dangerous than they really are?

I am a pilot, have my SCUBA certification, kayak and do other supposedly dangerous activities, and have a healthy respect for these tasks.  I have all my limbs/fingers, etc.  I know other pilots who have died in aircraft accidents, and one of my best friends was killed kayaking - but at the same time I know several people who have died in automobile accidents.  I know of no one who has died in a stationary machinery accident.

I agree that machinery needs to be respected, but the tone of this thread is that it's only a matter of time before you kill yourself/someone else unless you do exactly like I command.  I am troubled by that.  Maybe it's a US/European thing where people in the US take greater responsibility for their actions and actively rebel against the nanny state - Maybe not.

Any smokers here?  How about people who are overweight?

Let's try to put the true risks into some sort of perspective.

Timbo

3
Listeroid Engines / Re: KIT ENGINE, First impressions--
« on: August 23, 2006, 10:00:47 PM »
Easy way to tell if it is balance issue vs torque is to run it up to speed, note vibration and then shut off the fuel rack and open exhaust valve.

Immediately after fuel shutoff, during coast-down the nature of the vibration will change - motion at this point is balance related and not due to the powerstroke.

Try it - it's very noticable (for an engine not bolted to a ton of concrete).

Intuitively, the "chalk" method as described in "balancing out the bounce" thread seems easiest - and it appears that people who have done it have smooth running machines afterwards.


Timbo


4
Listeroid Engines / Re: I like the Kit idea...
« on: August 18, 2006, 07:12:55 PM »
Darren is correct.

There are no EPA rules regulating stationary recipricating internal combustion engines "RICE" that produce less than 500 hp. 

There are EPA rules regulating stationary RICE of greater than 500 hp

http://www.epa.gov/ttn/atw/rice/fr15jn04.html

There are EPA rules regulating "nonroad" engines

http://www.epa.gov/Compliance/resources/newsletters/civil/enfalert/engines.pdf

however, as defined by the EPA, stationary engines are not "nonroad" engines, and thus not subject to this regulation

http://ecfr.gpoaccess.gov/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=ecfr&sid=a9488629fb2412b3f05dad2bc253dd63&rgn=div8&view=text&node=40:20.0.1.1.3.1.1.2&idno=40

Law, by it's nature, does not ever say what is not regulated, only what is regulated - an example is that you cannot find a definative statement from any governing body stating that it is permissable to eat ice cream on a Tuesday.  What laws state are what is not permissable - you cannot exceed the posted speed limit on a highway. 

While the idea of a kit engine is not a bad one for the reasons stated, there is no need to "avoid an EPA ban"

Timbo

BTW, the 6/1 I received is mounted to a 6x6 frame and runs put some tire tread on the bottom of the wood and no walking on my garage floor - no issues yet - mounting a belt tensioner this weekend - hope to make my own electricity soon!


5
I could be blind, but I read:

"SUMMARY: This action promulgates national emission standards for
hazardous air pollutants (NESHAP) for stationary reciprocating internal
combustion engines (RICE) with a site-rating of more than 500 brake
horsepower (HP). "

Reading down further:

The final rule also does not apply to stationary RICE with a site-
rating of 500 brake HP or less. In reviewing the population database to identify
stationary RICE with a site-rating of 500 brake HP or less, we found
extremely little information. In discussions with State and local
permitting officials, the manufacturers, and some of the owners and
operators of stationary RICE, we found that such small stationary RICE
have generally not been regarded as significant sources of air
pollutant emissions. As a result, the small stationary RICE have not
been subjected to the same level of scrutiny, examination, or review as
larger stationary RICE. Little information has been gathered or
compiled by anyone for this subcategory of stationary RICE.
    Thus, at this point, we know very little about stationary RICE with
a site-rating of 500 brake HP or less. For example, we do not know how
many of the small stationary RICE exist. In addition, we know little
about the operating characteristics and emissions, the current use of,
as well as the applicability of, emission control technologies, the
costs of emission control for the small stationary RICE, or the
economic impacts and benefits associated with regulation. In the
absence of such information, we have concerns with the applicability of
HAP emission control technology to these stationary RICE. As a result,
we feel it is appropriate to defer a decision on regulation of
stationary RICE with a site-rating of 500 brake HP or less until
further information on the engines can be obtained and analyzed."

Maybe they are going to do more with these in the future, but this ruling does not affect my listeroid.

Timbo


6
Actually that proposal references stationary engines of greater than 500 brake horsepower - not applicable to my 6/1

Timbo

7
Why did I buy a listeroid?

The reason I told my wife?  It will make a reliable and quiet back-up power supply for our place at the coast that loses power on a regular basis.

The real reason?  It's cool and different with the flywheels and hand crank.  Plus I enjoy working on diesel engines (a CPA by trade, but really a frustrated engineer) - Rebuilt a 1959 Mercedes 190D with my grandfather the summer I was 16, and 20 some years later, I just got the oil out from under my fingernails from changing a timing belt on my VW diesel two weeks ago.  I could pay someone to ship me a diesel generator on a skid ready to go, but where is the fun in that?

This will be an opportunity to have another "toy" to play with that can be put to good use.

Timbo

Pages: [1]