Casey,
I get where you're coming from but I can tell you first-hand that the Bahamas is an AMAZING place! I was there many years ago for 4 months cruising to various islands (there are ~700 in the chain) and I STILL think of my time there and really miss it. There are very few placing in the world where it literally takes your breath away almost everyday. Amazing, amazing, amazing!
Then there's the aspect of the challenge that something like this brings. I don't know about you, but I like challenges as long as they don't result in complete devastation. Short of that, matching ones wits against something like this is scary, dangerous and a rush at the same time.
Like I wrote above, I hope everyone plays it smart and stays safe.
Steve